holidayexpt.com → online → cyber security army → whom versus which
Posted on by Cesar Arnold

whom versus which

Simple illustration showing 'whom' pointing to a person and 'which' pointing to an object

Use "whom" to refer to the object of a verb or preposition, typically in formal or written English; use "which" to refer to things, animals, or ideas. "Whom" is the objective form of "who"; "which" introduces relative clauses about non-human entities.

Both words function as relative pronouns, linking a clause to a noun or pronoun. "Whom" appears in formal constructions where the pronoun acts as the object of a verb or preposition. "Which" introduces clauses describing inanimate objects, animals, or abstract concepts. Misusing them often results in awkward phrasing or unclear references.

For example: "The person whom I met yesterday was late." Here, "whom" is the object of the verb "met." Contrast with: "The book which I read last week was long." "Which" refers to the book-a thing, not a person. Confusion arises when people apply "whom" to people in informal speech, where "who" or "that" is standard.

How each word functions in a sentence

"Whom" serves as the object of a verb or preposition. It replaces the indirect or direct object in a clause. In standard grammar, it follows prepositions like "to," "for," "from," or "about." For instance: "To whom did you send the letter?" Here, "whom" is the object of the preposition "to."

When a verb takes a direct object, "whom" still applies. Consider: "She gave the award to the student whom she admired most." The verb "admired" requires an object-the student. Even though "whom" appears later in the sentence, it refers to the recipient of admiration.

"Which" introduces a clause that describes a thing. It's not used for people unless referring to a group collectively, such as "the team which won the match." This usage is acceptable in formal writing, though many style guides prefer "that" for restrictive clauses. "Which" is often used in non-restrictive clauses set off by commas: "The house, which had a red door, sold quickly."

Common confusion and corrections

Many writers mistakenly use "who" instead of "whom" in formal contexts. For example: "Who did you see?" is acceptable in spoken English. But in formal writing, the correct form is "Whom did you see?" because "whom" is the object of the verb "see."

A frequent error is using "which" for people. Saying "The woman which helped me" is incorrect. The correct pronoun is "who" or "that." "Which" cannot refer to humans unless the reference is metaphorical or collective. For example: "The government, which has changed its policy, is under scrutiny." Here, "which" refers to the government as an entity, not individuals within it.

Another mistake is misplacing "whom" in complex sentences. In "The man whom I spoke to was late," "whom" correctly follows the preposition "to." However, in casual speech, people often say "The man who I spoke to was late"-a construction that's widely accepted in modern usage but technically incorrect in formal grammar.

Examples and distinctions

Use Case Correct Pronoun Example Sentence Explanation
Object of preposition (person) whom To whom did you give the keys? "Whom" is the object of "to."
Object of verb (person) whom The teacher whom we praised received an award. "Whom" is the object of "praised."
Description of a thing which The car which broke down was old. "Which" refers to the car-an object.
Non-restrictive clause (thing) which The painting, which was signed by the artist, sold for $50,000. Comma indicates non-restrictive clause; "which" adds extra detail.

Consider this real-world example: A news headline read, "The mayor, whom critics say lacks vision, faces re-election." The comma before "whom" signals a non-restrictive clause. The mayor is already identified; the clause adds commentary. Using "which" here-"The mayor, which critics say lacks vision..."-would be incorrect because "which" cannot refer to a person.

One non-obvious rule: "Whom" is not used after a verb in questions unless the preposition is moved. In "Who did you see?" the preposition "to" is implied. But in formal syntax, "To whom did you speak?" keeps "whom" after the preposition. This structure is rare in daily speech but essential in legal, academic, and official documents.

Real-world application and personal observation

I once edited a grant proposal where a researcher wrote: "The committee which reviewed our work recommended revisions." The sentence referred to a group of people. I corrected it to "The committee who reviewed our work recommended revisions" to maintain proper pronoun agreement. The original version used "which" for people, violating standard grammar rules.

Even in professional writing, errors persist. The Associated Press Stylebook (2023) states: "Use 'who' for people, 'which' for things, and 'that' for both when clarity is not compromised." This guideline reinforces that "which" should not replace "who" for human subjects.

Another authority, the Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed.), confirms: "Whom is the objective form of who and should be used when the pronoun is the object of a verb or preposition." It also notes that "which" is reserved for non-human antecedents unless used in a figurative sense.

What people often misunderstand

Some assume "whom" is obsolete or overly formal. While it's less common in everyday conversation, it remains correct in formal writing. Avoiding it entirely leads to ambiguity. For example: "I gave the file to the person who helped me" is fine. But "I gave the file to the person whom I trusted" is clearer and more precise.

Also, "which" is often misused in place of "that" in restrictive clauses. "The book which I bought yesterday" is grammatically correct but stylistically weaker than "The book that I bought yesterday." "That" is preferred in restrictive clauses-those that define the noun. "Which" is better for non-restrictive clauses with commas.

Finally, remember that "whom" doesn't change based on gender or identity. It's purely grammatical. Whether the person is male, female, or non-binary, the pronoun remains "whom" when serving as an object.

Understanding the difference between "whom" and "which" improves precision in writing. Use "whom" for people in object position; use "which" for things, animals, or abstract ideas. When in doubt, test the sentence: replace the pronoun with "him" or "it." If "him" fits, use "whom"; if "it" fits, use "which."


Related Posts