holidayexpt.com → mean national → poe switch 24 → is he a preposition
Posted on by Gerald Manning

Is He a Preposition?

Diagram showing parts of speech with 'is' highlighted as a linking verb, not a preposition

The word "is" is not a preposition. It is a linking verb, specifically the third-person singular form of the verb "to be." Prepositions govern noun phrases and show relationships between words, while "is" connects a subject to a subject complement.

Prepositions introduce prepositional phrases that typically consist of a preposition followed by a noun or pronoun. For example, "in the box," "on the table," or "under the bed." These phrases describe location, time, direction, or other spatial or logical relationships. "Is" does not introduce such a relationship-it expresses existence, identity, or state.

Consider the sentence: "He is in the room." Here, "is" links the subject "he" to the prepositional phrase "in the room." The preposition is "in," not "is." This structure follows the standard pattern: Subject + Verb (linking) + Complement (prepositional phrase).

How Prepositions Work

Prepositions establish relationships between nouns and other elements in a sentence. They often indicate location ("in," "on," "under"), time ("at," "before," "after"), or manner ("with," "without," "through").

For example, in "The book is on the shelf," "on" shows spatial relationship. In "She arrived at noon," "at" indicates time. These prepositions govern their objects-the noun or pronoun they precede-and function as the core of a prepositional phrase.

Prepositions do not act as verbs. They cannot stand alone as the main verb in a clause. You cannot say "The cat is on" and expect it to be a complete sentence. "On" requires an object to make sense. "Is" can stand alone as a verb: "He is." That's a valid sentence because "is" functions as a linking verb.

What "Is" Actually Is

"Is" belongs to the category of verbs known as copulas or linking verbs. These include forms of "to be" (am, is, are, was, were, be, being, been). They connect subjects to descriptions, states, or identities.

Take "She is happy." The word "is" links the subject "she" to the adjective "happy." The phrase "is happy" describes her emotional state. No preposition is involved. Similarly, "They are students" uses "are" to equate the subject with a noun group.

This function contrasts sharply with prepositions. A preposition like "in" would require an object: "in the classroom," "in the past." Without an object, "in" is incomplete. "Is" can be complete on its own: "Is he here?" is a grammatically correct question.

Common Confusions and Corrections

Many learners mistakenly assume that any word appearing before a noun is a preposition. This leads to errors like calling "is" a preposition because it appears before "in the room."

Another error arises from the similarity in sound and function between "is" and prepositions like "in" or "on." But "is" lacks the syntactic role of a preposition. It does not govern an object. Instead, it acts as a verb that links subject and predicate.

A non-obvious distinction: prepositions can be part of larger phrases, but they are not the main verb. In "The keys are on the counter," "are" is the verb, "on" is the preposition, and "the counter" is the object. The prepositional phrase "on the counter" modifies the location of the keys. "Are" is not a preposition-it's the linking verb.

Examples and Analysis

Let's analyze a few sentences to clarify:

Sentence Word in Question Role Reason
She is in the garden. is Linking verb Connects "she" to "in the garden," which is a prepositional phrase.
He is a teacher. is Linking verb Equates subject "he" with noun "teacher."
They are under the bridge. are Linking verb Subject "they" linked to prepositional phrase "under the bridge."
It is on the floor. is Linking verb Subject "it" connected to "on the floor," where "on" is the preposition.

In each case, "is" or "are" serves as the main verb. The preposition is always the word that introduces the object-never the linking verb.

Why This Matters in Language Learning

Mistaking "is" for a preposition leads to flawed parsing of sentence structure. This affects reading comprehension, writing accuracy, and grammar instruction.

According to the Cambridge Grammar of English (2002), linking verbs like "is" do not take direct objects. They take subject complements-adjectives, nouns, or prepositional phrases. Prepositions, by contrast, always take objects. This distinction is foundational in syntax.

I once taught a student who wrote: "The dog is in the house." She then asked, "Is 'in' the preposition?" I confirmed yes. But she insisted "is" was also a preposition because it came before "in." After diagramming the sentence, she saw that "is" connected "the dog" to the entire phrase "in the house"-not that it governed "in" as an object. That moment of clarity helped her move beyond surface-level confusion.

Further Reading


Related Posts